# re-bba-rb — bring-up TODO / findings (first physical unit)

Findings from bringing up the first assembled V1 board (repaired: 7 shorted
vias drilled out, some collateral trace damage). Started 2026-08-23. This is a
running list — items are **not** being worked yet, just recorded.

## Established good so far (context)

- Bitstream flashes + verifies (`iceprog`, channel A); FPGA configures (heartbeat).
- FT2232H healthy (channel-A MPSSE + channel-B internal loopback both pass).
- **W5100 clock confirmed GOOD** (Y2 25 MHz crystal oscillating): the on-board
  diagnostic (`scratchpad/w5100_check.py`) shows solid green — MR software-reset
  self-clears, which only happens on the internal clock.
- W5100 register write/read-back works on 7 of 8 data lines.

## Known damage on THIS unit (self-inflicted, from the via repair — not design bugs)

- **UART_RXD trace broken** (FPGA pin 19 → FT2232H pin 39). Workaround built:
  `UART_J4=1` synth build relocates the UART to the J4 header (DBG0=pin9=TX,
  DBG1=pin10=RX, GND=J4 pin1) for an external USB-UART/Pi dongle.
- **ETH_D3 trace broken** (W5100 data bit 3): net `ETH_D3` = FPGA **U9 pin 28**
  ↔ W5100 **U11 pin 40**. Confirmed by the diagnostic's red blink-code (4 blinks
  = D3). One bodge needed; bridge the drilled break (scrape to trace copper / a
  via — no need to touch the 0.5 mm chip pads). Optional: remap the FPGA D3 bit
  to a spare J4 pad (DBG2=pin11=J4 pin4) to make one end a coarse header pad.

---

## V2 schematic changes already applied (2026-08-25)

- **U7 EEPROM → 93LC56B** (LCSC C6164, MPN 93LC56BT-I/SN, same SOIC-8). Fixes the
  soft-brick (256 B is the FT2232H's full EEPROM size). [TODO/REVIEW updated]
- **All 7 LEDs → Everlight 24-21 reverse-mount 1206** (bottom-viewed, top-populated
  single-side assembly): red D7/D11 = **C2892757** (24-21SURC), green
  D6/D8/D9/D12 = **C2980185** (24-21/G6C), amber D13 = **C424133** (24-21UYC).
  All Vf ≈ 2.0 V (3.3 V-rail + SB_RGBA_DRV safe), moderate mcd. New footprint
  `hardware/LED_1206_ReverseMount_Everlight_24-21.kicad_mod` (pad1=cathode,
  **ø1.7 mm Edge.Cuts light-window — datasheet-confirmed** 2026-08-28, spec
  1.7 mm ±0.1). Refdes text is 1.0 mm (JLC silk floor).
- **LED series resistors R37/R41/R42: 49.9 Ω → 330 Ω** (reused existing part
  C25104; R38 already 330). ~3.9 mA vs the blinding ~26 mA — closes item 1's
  resistor half. Green PWM (`_GRN_DUTY`) in gateware still applies to D6/D12; the
  new green is only 18–45 mcd so it can likely be relaxed.
- **Gateware (`synth.py`):** RGB drive bug fixed (raw-pad `o_RGB*`) + green PWM
  dimming — see items 1 & 5.

Still open below: GC_ON handover redesign (#2), the datasheet-aperture verify,
EXI/W5100 functional validation (needs a working board), plus the ground-plane
fill for fab.

## TODO

### 1. LED brightness — LED_G and the two transistor-driven LEDs are blindingly bright

**Observation:** `LED_G` (D6, green) and the two transistor-driven LEDs are far
too bright; `LED_R` (D7, red) is fine.

**Root cause (from netlist):** the series resistors are wrong.
- `LED_R` (D7, red): **R38 = 330 Ω** → correct brightness (the reference).
- `LED_G` (D6, green): **R37 = 49.9 Ω** → ~25 mA, blinding.
- Transistor-driven: **D8** (green, via Q1 S8050) and **D9** (green, via Q2
  S8550, collector → **R42 = 49.9 Ω** → D9) → same over-drive. (Confirm D8's
  own series resistor value too.)

**Fix direction:** raise the 49.9 Ω LED series resistors (**R37**, **R42**, and
D8's) to ~**330 Ω–1 kΩ** to match D7. (The 49.9 Ω value looks copy-pasted from
the impedance-matching resistors — wrong part for an LED.) The RGB LED
(D11/D12/D13 via `SB_RGBA_DRV`, `RGB*_CURRENT=0b000001`) is separate and not
part of this complaint. BOM/PCB change for V2; a rework could tack larger
resistors on this unit if the brightness is a bench nuisance.

### 2. GC_ON was not a clean on/off (sat at 2.3 V; both handover LEDs on) — FIXED in schematic 2026-08-28

**Observation:** `GC_ON` measures **2.3 V** (not a clean rail). With **both USB
and GC connected**, both transistor-driven LEDs (D8, D9) are lit — the intent
was a power-handover indicator with only ever one active (USB vs GC).

**Analysis (from netlist):** `GC_ON` = TPS2116 status (net: U2.8 = mux ST,
U12.3, FPGA **U9 pin 21**, pulled up by R5 10 k to 3V3; drives Q1 base via R39
10 k and Q2 base via R40 10 k). The two indicator transistors are complementary
(Q1 = S8050 NPN, Q2 = S8550 PNP) expecting GC_ON to swing rail-to-rail:
- At **GC_ON ≈ 2.3 V**, the NPN (Q1, on when base ≳0.7 V) **and** the PNP (Q2, on
  when base ≲2.6 V) **both conduct** → both D8 and D9 light. There is no clean
  one-or-the-other point at this intermediate voltage.

**Root cause (identified 2026-08-28):** the intermediate ~2.3 V is **base-loading
of the open-drain ST node**. When GC is the source, ST is Hi-Z and *should* sit at
3V3 (R5 pull-up), but Q1's base (through R39 10 k) drags it down — R5‖R39 divide
3V3 to ~2.0 V — which is low enough that the PNP Q2's V_EB ≈ 1.3 V and it conducts
too. So both LEDs light, and the FPGA/EN see a soggy 2 V instead of 3V3.
TPS2116 ST is only characterised to sink **1 mA** (DS: V_OL @ I_ST = 1 mA,
t_ST @ R_ST = 10 k), so simply strengthening R5 is not allowed.

**Hardware fix — APPLIED 2026-08-28 (schematic):** raise the base resistors and
modestly lower the pull-up so GC_ON swings clean while ST stays ≤1 mA:
- **R5 10 k → 5.1 k** (C25905, reuses R6/R7 part)
- **R39 / R40 10 k → 33 k** (C25779, reuses R1 part)
Result: GC active → GC_ON ≈ **2.95 V** → Q1 saturates (D8/GC lit), Q2 V_EB ≈
0.35 V → OFF (D9/USB dark); USB active → ST low (sinks ~0.73 mA < 1 mA) → D9 lit,
D8 dark. Clean one-hot. **No new BOM lines, no PCB layout change** (resistor value
swaps only — run "Update PCB from Schematic" so the F.Fab values match). This also
**resolves the gateware concern below**: GC_ON now reads a solid ~2.95 V (well
above the iCE40 V_IH) instead of a marginal 2.3 V. D8/D9 = GC/USB is the confirmed
assignment (TPS2116 ST "low when VIN1 not used", VIN1 = GC priority — see
REVIEW.md); the B.SilkS labels are correct.
- ~~**Gateware:** GC_ON marginal at 2.3 V for the FPGA pin-21 read~~ — addressed
  by the fix above (now ~2.95 V). The "gate all outputs on GC_ON" work (TODO)
  can now assume a clean level; still verify on the reworked bench unit.

### 3. Functional W5100 test — send a packet capturable in Wireshark (works around broken D3?)

**Goal:** a test bitstream that makes the W5100 transmit a frame on the wire,
captured with Wireshark on the laptop (magjack J2 → laptop).

**Feasible:** reuse `W5100ParallelMaster` (MACRAW socket 0, or the UDP socket
path) with a small periodic trigger + a canned frame. Init runs on NCRA/startup.

**Caveat — the broken ETH_D3:** every byte written to the W5100 has data bit 3
corrupted, so a frame sent *now* would have wrong MAC/ethertype/payload bytes —
Wireshark might see a malformed frame (or the W5100 may reject a bad length).
- A garbled frame appearing at all would still prove **TX path + PHY + magnetics**
  work on the wire.
- For a **clean, valid** packet capture, do the **ETH_D3 bodge first** (item in
  "Known damage"). Recommended order: bodge D3 → re-run `w5100_check` (red should
  go dark) → then this packet test.

### 4. Bit-bang EXI from a Raspberry Pi to test the FPGA's EXI capture

**Goal:** validate the EXI Mode-3 capture front-end without a GameCube, by having
a Pi emulate the GC EXI master.

**Approach:** Pi SPI **master, Mode 3 (CPOL=1, CPHA=1)**, 3.3 V (both sides
3.3 V — no shifting). Drive the EXI **device-ID query** and check the response:
write `0x0000` (2 bytes) then read 4 bytes → must be **`0x04 0x02 0x02 0x00`**.
In SPI terms: assert CS, clock out `00 00 xx xx xx xx`, the last 4 MISO bytes are
the device ID. A match proves ExiCapture → register file → MISO end-to-end.

**Connections (FPGA EXI pins):** CLK=44, MOSI=4, MISO=3, CS=45 (INT=46) — reach
them at the SP1 edge connector J3 or the damper resistors (R21/R25). Map to Pi:
Pi SCLK→CLK, Pi MOSI→MOSI(FPGA in), Pi MISO←MISO(FPGA out), Pi CE→CS, GND↔GND.

**Notes:** run the Pi SPI **slow** (e.g., 1 MHz) — the capture domain oversamples
the EXI clock, so a slow clock is *easier* than the real 27 MHz and fully
exercises the Mode-3 logic + register file. Good first EXI smoke test before
trusting it against a real console.

### 5. RGB LEDs (D11 red / D12 green / D13 yellow) — drive bug + brightness

Two findings, from lighting them for the first time at bring-up:

**(a) DRIVE BUG — they don't light in the current gateware (functional, not cosmetic).**
`SB_RGBA_DRV`'s `o_RGB0/1/2` outputs are left as dangling internal signals in
`synth.py` (and were in the first test builds). nextpnr never bonds them to the
dedicated RGB pads (pins 39/40/41 — confirmed absent from the PCF), so the driver
outputs float and **the LEDs never light**. This means the **rx / tx / ready RGB
indicators are non-functional in the default build.**
- **Fix (confirmed on the bench):** request the RGB pins *raw* (no SB_IO buffer)
  and connect the driver outputs directly to the pads:
  ```python
  rgb = platform.request("rgbpad", 0, dir="-")   # Resource: r=39 g=40 b=41
  Instance("SB_RGBA_DRV", ...,
           o_RGB0=rgb.r.io, o_RGB1=rgb.g.io, o_RGB2=rgb.b.io)
  ```
  Connecting through a normal `dir="o"` request fails packing:
  `ERROR: SB_RGB_DRV/SB_RGBA_DRV port connected to more than just package pin!`
- **APPLIED 2026-08-23** in `synth.py`: added a raw `rgb` Resource (39/40/41) and
  wired `o_RGB0/1/2 = rgb.{r,g,b}.io`; the RGB indicators now light.

**(b) BRIGHTNESS — only GREEN (D12) is too bright; red (D11) and yellow (D13)
are fine.** Measured with the corrected drive at the driver's *minimum* current
(`CURRENT_MODE` half, `RGBx_CURRENT=0b000001`). The green die is much more
efficient per mA, so at the same minimum current it's blinding while red/yellow
look right. Since the current code is already at minimum, the fix is **PWM
dimming on green only** — feed a low-duty PWM into `RGB1PWM` (green) instead of a
static `1`, and leave red/yellow (`RGB0PWM`/`RGB2PWM`) driven solid.
- **APPLIED 2026-08-23** in `synth.py`: a `_GRN_DUTY` (default 2/16 ≈ 1/8) PWM now
  gates **both** green emitters — `RGB1PWM` (D12) and `LED_G`/D6 (the discrete
  heartbeat, over-bright from R37 — item 1). Red/yellow/LED_R stay solid. Tune
  `_GRN_DUTY` (0..15) at the bench. Gateware mitigation; the proper V2 hardware
  fix for D6 is still R37 → ~330 Ω (item 1).

### 6. (reserved — Dennis to add)

_Placeholder for the item Dennis was trying to recall._