Both from one mistake: eth_wr_valid is scheduled with m.d.sync and so is LOW
for the whole first cycle in a state, while eth_wr_ready was tested
immediately -- and `ready` is usually already high on entry. Both
valid.eq(1) and valid.eq(0) then fired in the same cycle, the later won, the
write was never issued, and it was dropped SILENTLY.
1. WRITE_LEN_HI dropped the descriptor's HIGH length byte, leaving it at its
placeholder 0x00. Hardware read a descriptor of 00 00 00 01 -- a 1-byte
frame length, impossible for ethernet -- and rejected the ring.
2. WRITE_PLACEHOLDER counted a phantom first write, advancing wr_addr without
issuing one. Only THREE placeholder bytes were written and wr_addr ended
at desc_base+3, so the frame body started at descriptor byte 3 and EVERY
RECEIVED FRAME WAS SHIFTED ONE BYTE EARLY. The GC's ethertype test then
read the wrong offset and silently dropped every frame: the host saw "no
ACK" while the ring filled and RWP advanced normally.
Both now advance on `valid & ready`, and the body offset is set explicitly
(desc_base + 4) rather than relying on an incremented pointer, so it cannot
drift with the handshake again.
WHY NO TEST CAUGHT THIS, which is the more important half:
- The testbench drove the RX stream OPEN-LOOP -- one byte per tick, never
checking rx_ready, which is low through IDLE and the whole placeholder
write. It silently lost bytes, including the SOF byte. A real master
must hold each byte until accepted.
- It only ever asserted on rwp and rx_irq. It declared a spram_writes list
and never filled it, so NOTHING had ever checked what was written.
- Every frame it sent was short, and a short frame's high length byte is
legitimately zero -- so a dropped high byte was indistinguishable from a
correct one.
The testbench now respects back-pressure, records every write, and checks the
descriptor bytes and the body offset. T2 sends a 300-byte frame specifically
so the high length byte is non-zero. Mutation-tested: restoring either bug
fails T2 with got [0,0,0,48] want [0,0,1,48] -- the same shape as the
hardware's 00 00 00 01 -- while T1 (short frame) still passes, which is
exactly the blind spot that let this ship.
Bring-up's 342-byte DHCP frame read a correct 00 00 01 5A only because the
arbiter happened to hold `ready` low on that entry cycle; the domain merge
and the SPRAM response-FIFO removal changed that timing.
--seeds 8: clk 27.8-32.2 MHz, EXI 54.9-64.5 MHz, 8/8 PASS. Best seed 8
(clk 32.22, EXI 62.25), flashed. Gateware only -- the .dol is unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Roflin
Dennis Brentjes