Roflin
cb0df55699
Swiss hung on "setting up device" while the server logged perfectly reasonable
GET_PRO replies. fsplib was dropping every one and retrying -- visible in the
log as the same request repeating with the low 3 sequence bits counting up,
since fsp_transaction encodes the retry number there.
FSP has TWO checksum formulas and they differ by the packet length:
fsp_pkt_write (what a client SENDS):
checksum = sum(bytes, sum byte zeroed) + used
sum_byte = checksum + (checksum >> 8)
fsp_pkt_read (what a client ACCEPTS):
mysum = sum(bytes) - sum_byte <- no length term at all
ok if ((mysum + (mysum >> 8)) & 0xff) == sum_byte
cube/patches/bba/tcpip.c matches the WRITE form (`sum = size` to start) and
never verifies replies, so the in-game path tolerated our packets; the menu's
fsplib did not. Replies are now built the way fsp_pkt_read verifies.
Incoming requests are accepted under either formula, since a tolerated request
is far easier to diagnose than a rejected one.
⚠️ The self-test passed throughout the bug, and that is the part worth
remembering: it verified replies with the SERVER'S OWN checksum function, so
the two agreed with each other and disagreed with Swiss. Identical in shape to
the RX descriptor format, where our writer, our readers and our tests were all
self-consistent and all wrong. The test now transcribes fsp_pkt_read literally
as fsplib_verify() and checks every reply against that, and mutating the server
back to the with-length formula fails it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>